Home / Review
The Guild 1 Remake: Europa 1410 Review
Guild nostalgia, handsome towns, and cart logistics that fall apart

Contents
The Guild 1 Remake: Europa 1410: 69% positive from 855 Steam reviews, 24-hour peak of 124 players, priced at $22.49, SteamGame.ai potential score 60/100 (data as of 2026-11-19). Source: SteamGame.ai (Find the next hit before it hits.)
Pros
- Generations, trades and a political ladder worth climbing
- A faithful remake that gives Guild veterans their town back
- A chill soundtrack, German voice acting and handsome towns
Cons
- Cart handling that breaks as soon as you expand
- Managers who dump your raw stock and wreck a working shop
- Laws, taxes and prices that barely respond
Your first workshop in The Guild 1 Remake: Europa 1410 stands or falls on a cart, and every workshop you add after it does the same. The frame comes from the original The Guild: pick a trade such as smith, preacher or alchemist, haul raw goods into your shop, turn them into something worth more, sell the stock, and push the family up through guild and council while the years roll past. Much of that climb still lands. Many players point to the professions, the heirs and the political ladder as the reason to keep going, and several call the remake a faithful homecoming for anyone who loved the first game. The break sits in the supply line. Cart handling is thin enough that seven post-launch reviews call it missing or inadequate, and six describe hired managers who take the carts, dump raw materials on the market and sink a business that ran fine under manual control. Steam currently labels the game Mixed across 850 reviews, and that split tracks how much of the game leans on the part that misbehaves.
Logistics break first
The loop is plain on purpose, and the players who like it say so: buy low, refine, sell high, reinvest. Scaling it is where the wheels come off. Carts ferry material in and finished goods out, and one review calls the absence of cart automation a late-game killer, while another says keeping track of more than two or three businesses by hand is close to impossible. Delegation makes it worse. A manager handed a shop will load your carts for errands of their own, sell the barley and malt you bought instead of brewing with it, and undercut your own purchase price at the counter. One tavern keeper describes buying supplies outside the city walls for less than a manager paid for the same goods inside them, then losing the delivery to a robbery within sight of the market. Complaints about carts and managers run through reviews posted into mid-October, the newest of them in our sample.
Would not recommed 30 bucks for nothing game is really bad compared to the original
Laws and prices that barely move
A management game needs its systems to push back, and the push is what is missing. Thirteen post-launch reviews describe core systems as absent or shallow and the middle game as repetitive; seven describe an economy and a political layer that fail to function. Players name taxes that never seem to collect, laws that pass with no visible effect, and markets where supply and demand hardly registers. One review from late October says politics can be ignored and the economy is stagnant. Another player wanted to be a blacksmith, then found that you hire the labour and never work the forge yourself. A long save does not fix it either. One review, updated after version 0.4.5, said the game had become playable but still felt the same on every run, whatever profession or goal was chosen.

The parts that hold up tend to be the ones the remake inherited. Choosing a trade, opening a shop, marrying, raising an heir and buying into office give the sandbox its pull, and a newcomer who never played the earlier games describes steady enjoyment from exactly that. Veterans split along a clean line: come wanting The Guild 1 and you get it, come wanting The Guild 2 and you should stay away. A few players also pick out the smaller pleasures, including a chill soundtrack, a German voice cast and towns that look good enough to make the menu screens feel like a waste. The same handful mention the spread of maps, town backstory, victory conditions and a free mode as reasons to start again with a different setup. Two reviews note that this launch went more smoothly than The Guild 3's did, which for this series counts as progress.
The clock and the popups
Interface friction shows up in four reviews, with players describing notification spam, windows that pile up and a cart arrival message repeated until it stops carrying information. Family life needs guardrails the build does not have. A few players describe heirs marrying without permission, one a 20-year-old heir wedding a 50-year-old stranger, another a child bringing home a partner the family head never approved. Time adds its own pressure. One newcomer asks for an age toggle so decisions can be made at a walking pace, and one review reports that the second generation starts near the bottom of the ladder with fewer political openings than the first run had.
You want Guild 1, you get Guild 1. You want Guild 2? Stay away then.
Rough edges and a language gap
Performance is uneven. Three reviews report stutter and crashes, with one player noting that carts and workers move smoothly while the avatar and the townsfolk hitch, and another got soft-locked by a mission that would not register as complete. Language is the harder wall for part of the audience. A few Chinese-language reviews ask for a Mandarin edition, one posted the day after launch and another in the first week. Several reviews say the build went out before it was ready, and the crash reports back that up.

Four reviews argue that what is in the box does not justify the asking price, and one of those advises waiting a year or two and buying on discount. The counterweight is the patch cadence. Five reviews, the newest from mid-November, credit the developers with hotfixes, a Discord where feedback gets read and steady updates, and one furious write-up from launch week was edited after a hotfix to say the game had become playable. A player who could see the foundation under the mess says it is good and worth waiting on. That is a fair bet for a remake in Early Access. It is still a bet.
This review is based on 65 Steam player reviews and store data. See all reviews on Steam →
Quick answers
Do I need to have played the original The Guild?
No. Several post-launch reviews come from newcomers, including one who never touched the earlier games and describes steady enjoyment of the generational climb. Veterans are the divided group: some call it a faithful return to the first game, while others say fans of The Guild 2 should stay away. That rests on several reviews, so read it as a pattern rather than a settled answer.
How long before the management load gets out of hand?
One detailed post-launch review puts the turn at the second generation plus a second business, roughly 13 hours of deliberate play. Other reviews describe the same wall without a timestamp, saying that more than two or three shops becomes unmanageable by hand. Treat the hour count as one player's experience, not a fixed figure.
By the NumbersUpdated 2026-11-19. Data updates on a daily schedule.
- Potential score
- 60 list metric, not a quality score
- Positive (all languages)
- 69% Mixed
- Total reviews (all languages)
- 855
- New reviews/day (7d)
- 2
- Peak players (24h)
- 124
- Price
- $22.49
- Release date
- Sep 17, 2026
- Developer
- Ashborne Games
- Publisher
- THQ Nordic
- Est. sales
- 25.6K~51.3K rough estimate from review count
Source: public Steam store pages and player reviews. Review counts, positive share and daily new reviews cover all languages; the player peak is the highest count in the last 24 hours; estimated sales are a rough estimate based on review count, for reference only. Updated 2026-11-19; data updates on a daily schedule. Methodology
Daily New Reviews (all languages)
Is interest rising or fading?
Developer View
- Developer
- Ashborne Games
- Publisher
- THQ Nordic
- Developer's games on Steam
- 3 incl. this one; matched by developer name, may be off
- Early Access
- In Early Access
The store page has no AI-generated content disclosure.



