Home / Review

Shelve the Potions! Review

Clever shelf puzzles, cats to pet, and a back half that drags

Contents
  1. The upgrades never take off
  2. Squinting at symbols
  3. Cats, cosiness and one cellar
  4. Verdict
  5. Quick answers
  6. By the Numbers
At a glance

Shelve the Potions!: 87% positive from 680 Steam reviews, 24-hour peak of 64 players, priced at $5.99, SteamGame.ai potential score 72/100 (data as of 2026-11-19). Source: SteamGame.ai (Find the next hit before it hits.)

Pros

  • Shelf-order puzzles that make sorting think
  • Cats, a cosy cellar and no AI art
  • A cat-given hint when a puzzle bites

Cons

  • Puzzle types dry up by the third colour
  • Upgrades that never feel powerful
  • Symbols and bottle shapes hard to tell apart
$5.9987% positiveRising-list metric 72 View on Steam →

Two thousand potions sit on the floor of a witch's cellar, and the cats who knocked them there are still padding about, available for petting. Shelve the Potions! is a casual organising puzzle game about getting every bottle back on its shelf, and the order is something you have to work out first. Steam buyers have pushed it to Very Positive, with 87 percent of 675 reviews recommending it in mid-November. The best idea in it is that each shelf wants a solved order rather than a copied number, and several players say that twist is what lifts the game above a crowded field. The problem underneath is volume. Players report the puzzle types run out long before the shelves do, and the back half becomes lookup work.

The opening hours earn the praise. Clues are spread around the cellar. Symbols sit on props, notes need deciphering, and certain potions match an object across the room. Solve one and you learn the order for a shelf. Clear a colour and crystals pay for abilities that pull matching bottles into your hand. One player describes taking real notes, loving the escape-room feel, and says the puzzle layer is what made the game stand out from the wave of tidy-up releases. Then the puzzles stop arriving. Several players say they had seen every puzzle type by the second or third colour, and there are 13 colours in all. One counts 1,984 bottles across 272 shelves, answered by 28 solutions. What is left is picking bottles up, opening the reference list and matching symbols row by row. A player who reached the end said they were waiting for the game to finish rather than enjoying the tidy shelves.

It's a very fun and actually unique "sort these things" game :3 The puzzles are a twist and I like that you can disable the abilities for the "do the run without abilities" achievement. :)
Steam player · Recommended · 14 h played · Nov 8, 2026 · See all reviews on Steam →

The upgrades never take off

Upgrades never build into the power fantasy this genre trades on. Half a dozen reviews land on the same complaint. The abilities stay small, cooldowns run from 40 seconds to about a minute, and the gathering spell adds five bottles at a time, so an eight-bottle shelf still sends you hunting the floor by hand. One player wanted a late-game auto-sort for the hand or the shelf. Another asked for cooldowns short enough that a fully upgraded run feels like a reward. Across 13 colour sections, that flat curve turns the middle of the game into manual labour.

Shelve the Potions!
Shelve the Potions! · screenshot via Steam

Squinting at symbols

Reading the shelves is harder than it needs to be. Five players mention symbols that blur together, a reference panel too small to check at a glance, and bottle shapes and colours that look alike. One polygon-counting puzzle drew particular complaints about eye strain. Two reviews from launch week report bugs, one stuck in the starting room and one losing an item's info while it was held. No review posted after that week in our sample repeats either problem, so the current build may already have them fixed.

The game asks you to think before you tidy, and that demand splits the people who buy it. Several players who came for pure relaxation say the puzzles slowed the sorting and left them tired rather than soothed, and a few wanted nothing more than numbered shelves. The hint system softens the wall. Three players mention asking a cat for a nudge or the full answer, and one says the option makes the puzzles easy if that is how you want to play. Others call the sheer amount of shelving good value for what they paid. Our read is that the tags sell two different games, one restful and one puzzling, and the game leans much harder on the second.

It was really good for the first bit. but then all the puzzles just repeat and the shelves they go on is very obvious, so there's no thought between the rest of the shelves, its just tedious work.
Steam player · Not recommended · 3 h played · Nov 6, 2026 · See all reviews on Steam →

Cats, cosiness and one cellar

The mood carries a lot of goodwill. Five players single out the cats and the cosy cellar, and petting the cats gets mentioned on its own as a reason to smile. Four players note that the game contains no AI-generated art and count it as a plus. A couple praise the options menu, which covers brightness, field of view, colourblind support, separate audio sliders and saving whenever you like. The setting itself is thin. Several players complain that the potions carry no lore and the cellar is the only place you ever see, so the scenery never changes from the first shelf to the last.

Shelve the Potions!
Shelve the Potions! · screenshot via Steam

This review is based on 66 Steam player reviews and store data. See all reviews on Steam →

Quick answers

How long does a full playthrough take?

Reports vary with how much you chase. One player describes a single run to 100 percent at about 11 hours, while another, with 53.6 hours on record, calls it the longest game they have played and says they reached the end. That is two individual accounts rather than a firm range, so the length depends on how many of the 13 colour sections you clear.

Can you finish the game without using the abilities?

Players describe an achievement for completing a run with abilities disabled, and three of them mention the no-magic route, with one saying they cleared it before upgrading anything. The support here is a handful of reviews, so treat the option as real but not deeply documented.

By the NumbersUpdated 2026-11-19. Data updates on a daily schedule.

RelaxingOrganizingCollectathonCasualPuzzleHidden ObjectCats
Potential score
72 list metric, not a quality score
Positive (all languages)
87% Very Positive
Total reviews (all languages)
680
New reviews/day (7d)
1
Peak players (24h)
64
Price
$5.99
Release date
Aug 24, 2026
Developer
Knight Owl Games
Publisher
Knight Owl Games
Est. sales
20.4K~40.8K rough estimate from review count

Source: public Steam store pages and player reviews. Review counts, positive share and daily new reviews cover all languages; the player peak is the highest count in the last 24 hours; estimated sales are a rough estimate based on review count, for reference only. Updated 2026-11-19; data updates on a daily schedule. Methodology

Daily New Reviews (all languages)

Is interest rising or fading?

2026-10-20: 3 positive, 0 negative2026-10-21: 2 positive, 1 negative2026-10-22: 3 positive, 0 negative2026-10-23: 2 positive, 0 negative2026-10-24: 6 positive, 1 negative2026-10-25: 3 positive, 0 negative2026-10-26: 2 positive, 0 negative2026-10-27: 1 positive, 1 negative2026-10-28: 3 positive, 0 negative2026-10-29: 1 positive, 0 negative2026-10-30: 2 positive, 0 negative2026-10-31: 0 positive, 0 negative2026-11-01: 1 positive, 1 negative2026-11-02: 1 positive, 0 negative2026-11-03: 1 positive, 0 negative2026-11-04: 2 positive, 0 negative2026-11-05: 1 positive, 1 negative2026-11-06: 1 positive, 1 negative2026-11-07: 4 positive, 0 negative2026-11-08: 4 positive, 0 negative2026-11-09: 2 positive, 1 negative2026-11-10: 3 positive, 1 negative2026-11-11: 0 positive, 0 negative2026-11-12: 4 positive, 1 negative2026-11-13: 0 positive, 0 negative2026-11-14: 0 positive, 0 negative2026-11-15: 2 positive, 1 negative2026-11-16: 1 positive, 0 negative2026-11-17: 0 positive, 0 negative2026-11-18: 2 positive, 1 negative
Positive / dayNegative / day2026-10-20 → 2026-11-18

Developer View

Developer
Knight Owl Games
Publisher
Knight Owl Games
Developer's games on Steam
8 incl. this one; matched by developer name, may be off
Early Access
No
AI-generated content

The store page has no AI-generated content disclosure.

Games like Shelve the Potions! →

Potential 72Shelve the Potions!$5.99Steam →