Home / Review
Thief Simulator 3: First Loot Review
Rough visuals, slow progression, and bugs bog down this free demo.

Contents
Thief Simulator 3: First Loot: 46% positive from 327 Steam reviews, 24-hour peak of 60 players, priced at Free, SteamGame.ai potential score 51/100 (data as of 2026-11-19). Source: SteamGame.ai (Find the next hit before it hits.)
Pros
- Fast loading times and smooth performance on some systems
- Promising four-player co-op and street-level pickpocketing
- Clearer percentage-based stealth detection bar and post-job summaries
Cons
- Stiff animations, rough visuals, and clashing futuristic UI
- Sluggish early-game progression with low loot values
- Frequent collision bugs, clunky movement, and uneven frame rates
Prying open neighborhood windows, stuffing electronics into your backpack, and fencing stolen goods at the local pawn shop form the foundation of Thief Simulator 3: First Loot. Developed by Noble Muffins and published by PlayWay S.A., this free-to-play work-in-progress tech demo introduces up to four-player co-op alongside solo burglary. Across 327 Steam reviews, only 46% are positive for an overall Mixed rating, as returning series fans question both its rough execution and its creative direction. Many players credit its fast loading times and smooth performance on select setups, while a few reviews highlight the promise of four-player heists and a clearer stealth detection meter. Even so, many reviews criticize the stiff character animations and dated visuals, a clashing user interface, sluggish skill progression, and frequent collision bugs.
Casing the Neighborhood
The core loop of gathering intel, sneaking past residents and police, and selling haul at a nearby pawn shop brings a few welcome street-level additions, even if the playable slice remains thin. One player who completed the demo in 7.7 hours praises the addition of story missions for giving each heist a clearer sense of direction than simple back-to-back contracts. A 26.7-hour review details the prologue setup, where you choose among three characters (Joey, Morgan, or Kim) to work off rent for a shady landlord in District 7, and praises both the new percentage-based stealth detection bar and the ability to pickpocket pedestrians right outside the pawn shop. Post-heist summary screens and expanded street interactions, such as opening trash cans, lifting manhole covers, and sleeping on roadside benches, also earn nods in a couple of reviews. Up to four friends can rob houses together in co-op, which a couple of players see as a promising evolution, though one October review argues that multiplayer and selectable protagonists pull the series away from its single-player roots. At the same time, a few reviews point out that the demo only opens up two to four houses or rooms to rob and keeps higher upgrade tiers locked.
This is one pretty good thief game i like how it's got Multiplayer i like it alot better than thief simulator 1 & 2.
A Penniless Start
Getting your criminal career off the ground feels frustratingly restrictive due to abrupt onboarding and a stingy economy. Many players criticize the opening tutorial and alarm pacing. Instead of easing you into lockpicking and stealth like earlier installments, the prologue triggers an immediate alarm and forces a getaway before you can get your bearings, while low-contrast prompt boxes and distant parking lot signs leave newcomers guessing where to go. Once you reach the neighborhood, many reviews complain that earning cash and leveling up drags at a crawl. Basic level-one lockpicking sits locked behind character level three, early-game gadgets like micro-cameras and drones are unavailable, and stolen items sell for pennies while tools remain expensive. One October review points out that a stolen television fetches only about $2.3 (15 CNY) at the pawn shop, leaving early-game thieves to scavenge soda cans from trash bins after robbing the convenience store.

Plastic Models and GPS Menus
Presentation draws the sharpest backlash from series veterans, who frequently compare the look and feel unfavorably to the previous two installments. Although one reviewer finds the light-blue tech interface cleaner than an earlier orange demo layout and another notes a slight bump in visual fidelity, many players pan the UI as a cheap, futuristic eyesore that clashes with a grounded burglary setting. One October review compares the HUD and minimap to a 2000s car GPS, while a November review notes that you cannot even change the language in the settings before creating a save file and reading untranslated difficulty prompts. Visuals and character animations fare no better. Many reviews describe plastic-looking 3D models, glaring or murky lighting, repetitive asphalt textures, and stiff, expressionless NPCs whose cutscene movements and erratic routines look like a step backward from earlier entries.
Mechanical jank and uneven technical performance further disrupt the stealth sandbox. Many players report clunky movement and awkward driving controls. Crouching prevents you from sprinting directly into a run or climbing through windows, carrying heavy loot disables jumping, and climbing onto a car roof can trap your character in mid-air. While one review finds the driving handling acceptable and similar to the second game, other reviews dislike the deep, restricted first-person cockpit view and the removal of side-door car entry. Collision and interaction bugs crop up across many reviews, as characters clip through walls when opening doors, box-opening minigames fail to respond, exiting a passenger seat warps you to the driver's side, and getting wedged behind houses is worse without an unstuck button. Police behavior also draws mixed reactions, with one review welcoming that officers no longer phase through walls while others call the cops brainless or complain that jumping near a house triggers endless alarms. On the technical side, several players praise fast loading times and clean frame rates even on laptops or mechanical hard drives, yet many others report severe frame drops, stuttering, and a six-minute loading screen.
The 6 minutes i spent in the loading screen were very exciting
This review is based on 66 Steam player reviews and store data. See all reviews on Steam →
Quick answers
What happens if you accept a co-op invite while playing solo?
One player reports a bug where accepting a friend's lobby invite during a single-player session does nothing instead of saving your progress and joining the multiplayer lobby, and also notes that the pause menu lacks an option to return to the main menu without closing the game.
How do vehicle parking and saving work between heists?
Two reviews point out that walking back to your hideout leaves your car behind in the neighborhood rather than returning it automatically, though one player notes you can pay $10 at a parking lot to tow it back. One November review also points out that you cannot manually save mid-session, as progress only saves when exiting the game.
By the NumbersUpdated 2026-11-19. Data updates on a daily schedule.
- Potential score
- 51 list metric, not a quality score
- Positive (all languages)
- 46% Mixed
- Total reviews (all languages)
- 327
- New reviews/day (7d)
- 3
- Peak players (24h)
- 60
- Price
- Free
- Release date
- Oct 14, 2026
- Developer
- Noble Muffins
- Publisher
- PlayWay S.A.
- Est. sales
- 9,810~19.6K rough estimate from review count
Source: public Steam store pages and player reviews. Review counts, positive share and daily new reviews cover all languages; the player peak is the highest count in the last 24 hours; estimated sales are a rough estimate based on review count, for reference only. Updated 2026-11-19; data updates on a daily schedule. Methodology
Daily New Reviews (all languages)
Is interest rising or fading?
Developer View
- Developer
- Noble Muffins
- Publisher
- PlayWay S.A.
- Developer's games on Steam
- 7 incl. this one; matched by developer name, may be off
- Early Access
- No
The store page has no AI-generated content disclosure.



