Home / AI Game News / Takes

AI Multiplies Supply. Players Are Applying a Discount.

A Tencent Research Institute roundtable says AI has pressed the multiply key on game development. We checked three and a half months of new Steam releases. So far the multiplier only shows up on the production side.

The original piece is the Tencent Research Institute roundtable published on November 18, "AI Pressed the Multiply Key on Game Development" (in Chinese).

The loudest line in the roundtable comes from Xiong Panfeng, a vice president at the Chinese indie games company Duli Zhiguang. In Xiong's telling, before AI the value a beginner and a top developer could create differed by one to a hundred; now it is ten to a hundred thousand. Everyone's floor has risen, and the ceiling has risen even more. We agree with the first half. We cannot find the second half on Steam. New games that disclose AI use reach big numbers less often, and the ones that do reach them are rated lower. Games that pass model costs on to players get negative reviews written specifically about that money.

The roundtable gets real things right. Xiong spent five hours tuning a wingman character who swoops in to save a new player about to be hit by a missile, which Xiong says would have been impossible before. Xiaoning, who runs 405 Youju, points out that one more player costs a traditional game almost nothing, while every new player of an AI game adds model fees. We have no quarrel with either point.

The weakness is the evidence. The whole piece argues that AI raises the ceiling using interviews, focus groups and hackathon anecdotes, without a single number on how games sold or how players rated them. The roundtable itself leaves the player side for a later discussion. Players have been leaving Steam reviews for months already. Here are three things we found in them.

Fewer AI games break out, and those that do are rated lower

We counted 2,383 new Steam games released since August 1, 2026 with at least 20 reviews and a checked store page. Of these, 706, about 30%, disclose AI-generated content on their store page. If AI raised the ceiling, that 30% should be overrepresented at the top. It is the other way round. Among the 358 games with 500 or more reviews, AI-disclosing games make up 19%. Among the 211 games past 1,000 reviews, there are only 32 of them, or 15%, roughly half their share of all new games.

Disclosed AI-generated contentNo disclosure
Games7061,677
Median positive rate81%87%
Median review count5884
Share with 500+ reviews9.8%17.2%
Games with 1,000+ reviews (median positive rate)32 (76%)179 (85%)

Xu Yiran, CEO of MultiMetaverse Inc., warns in the roundtable that low-quality, mass-produced AI games are multiplying. That explains why AI-disclosing games score lower overall. It does not explain the top tier. Among games past 1,000 reviews, the median positive rate is 76% for AI-disclosing games and 85% for the rest, a 9-point gap between games that have all found an audience. One player's positive review of Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker says they used to assume AI games were all slapdash. A positive English review of Astrobuilder opens with "Despite this game having AI".

Three games passed model costs to players, and all three drew reviews about it

The roundtable lists monthly passes, pay-per-use, buy-to-play plus in-app purchases and bring-your-own API key, and concludes there is "no standard answer yet". We read sampled reviews of four new games that call a model while you play. Three of them make players pay for model usage in some form, and in all three, some players wrote negative reviews about it.

A caption in the roundtable says buying crystals in Magi Scapes is not necessary to experience the game's core content. Players in its review section disagree. After buying the game, you still spend crystals to create each new companion, and one English-language player worked out that the bundled crystals cover only 4 of them. That player called it "an infinite money sink". In the 29 negative reviews we sampled, about half concern the pricing, limits, queues or answer quality of the AI features. Its positive rate is 65%.

In Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker, talking to NPCs uses up energy. One negative review notes that you have to pay to refill it, and a player who left a positive review still complained that "the limited tokens suck". Two English negative reviews of Scam With Your Friends say the developers asked players for donations in the game and on Discord because they could not afford the AI. Most of that game's negative reviews are about its microphone and privacy, and the donations are one item among them.

Xiaoning's point that marginal cost is no longer zero describes the studio's problem. These three review sections show that players have no intention of sharing it, and they say so in their reviews once the cost becomes visible.

The roundtable's model of restraint draws complaints at the exact step where it calls the model

Restraint in the roundtable means fewer model calls and smaller models, and its example is Astrobuilder. Its 600 NPCs follow preset rules most of the time and call a 27B model only for key interactions. The game is 88% positive, yet the complaints in its reviews cluster on precisely that key interaction, having to type out arguments to haggle with NPCs while trading. One player with 45 hours suggested renaming it something like Awkward Small Talk Simulator. Trading is the action players repeat most, and a cheaper model call does not shorten the typing.

Two other games go the opposite way. Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker is built around interrogation, with every NPC voiced by the model and no preset dialogue options. Since its August 21 release, it has 476 reviews at 88% positive. One English-language player summed it up as "Free conversation is the core, not just replacing fixed options with an input box." Scam With Your Friends has players phone AI-voiced callers and con them, and with over five thousand reviews it ranks ninth among AI-disclosing new games. Both have plenty of negative reviews, mostly about bugs, voice recognition and privacy, plus some saying the AI is too dumb. Almost nobody says talking to the AI is a pointless feature.

Our read is that the roundtable treats restraint as spending less on the model, while players care about where the model sits. In these three games, when talking to the AI is the game itself, players put up with the rough edges.

Where this could be wrong

AI disclosures are written by developers. No disclosure does not mean no AI, and disclosed uses range from translation and art assets to live dialogue. A difference between the two groups shows correlation only, since studios using AI may simply be smaller and poorer. We chose the four games ourselves and read a few dozen sampled reviews for each. The data covers three and a half months, AI tools change every six months, and these numbers may look different in a few months. We will keep counting.

For anyone building an AI game

The roundtable says to do the math before greenlighting a project. We agree, and would add the player's side to it. First ask whether players come for the AI interaction or for some other game. If it is the latter, keep model calls off the action they repeat every session. Then check whether the model bill reaches the player as crystals, energy, daily limits or donation requests.

Review counts and positive rates cover all languages on Steam, taken from each game's latest reading (November 15 to 18). AI-generated content disclosures come from Steam store pages and are written by developers. Player reviews were sampled; quotes from Chinese reviews are paraphrased.