Home / AI Game News / Takes

Grand Theft Auto VI's User Score Was Dragged Down, Yet Three Complaints Are Checkable Product Facts

Dexerto and jeuxvideo.com blame review-bombing for the Metacritic drop on Grand Theft Auto VI, and SteamGame.ai agrees the score was dragged down while finding three verifiable product facts inside the complaints.

Illustration: SteamGame.ai

On November 21, Dexerto reported that Grand Theft Auto VI and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake were being review-bombed on Metacritic as fans appeared to target each other's games. On the same day, jeuxvideo.com reported overnight review-bombing on Metacritic and pointed to zero scores linked to rival fanbases and cultural grievances. SteamGame.ai agrees that votes unrelated to the game pulled the Metacritic user score down.

We disagree with the conclusion that the low score therefore carries no useful signal for people making games. SteamGame.ai's judgment is that an open Metacritic score sitting in the fives cannot measure the quality of Grand Theft Auto VI, yet three complaints repeating across low scores and X posts map onto checkable product facts.

The strongest case for dismissing the Metacritic user score rests on a critic Metascore of 99 recorded across three separate launch-week tallies. GamesIndustry.biz counted 167 Metacritic reviews in the opening hours of the November 18 embargo, Business Insider cited 151 reviews on November 20, and GGRecon reported 152 critic reviews on the PS5 page on the morning of November 21.

On the user side, GGRecon noted that Metacritic does not require anyone to own a game before posting a rating. Leaving scoring open to non-buyers exposes any headline average whenever a major release attracts organized campaigns.

Purchase gates separate verified buyers from open-entry scoreboards

Most launch-week coverage argues over whether Metacritic is fair while leaving out the structural divide between open boards and purchase-gated storefronts. Separating scores by whether a rater had to buy the game produces two sharply different readings. On the PlayStation Store, where only buyers can rate Grand Theft Auto VI, GGRecon reported a score of 4.84 out of 5 from about 170,000 ratings on November 21.

When GGRecon checked the open PS5 Metacritic page that same morning, the user score sat at 5.5 from 34,804 ratings. Those two scales measure different pools and cannot be converted into one number, yet the gap shows how much an ownership gate changes who gets counted. SteamGame.ai follows that same boundary across this site by relying solely on Steam reviews, which also require owning the game.

Unrelated votes account for part of the Metacritic drop

Open entry allowed votes with no connection to gameplay to enter the Metacritic tally immediately. Dexerto reported on November 21 that some accounts had rated only two games in total, giving Grand Theft Auto VI a 0 out of 10 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake a 10 out of 10. On November 21, jeuxvideo.com reported that the Metacritic user score dropped as low as 4.9 out of 10 before recovering to 5.5, pointing to The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time fans and complaints calling the game "woke" alongside players citing frame-rate drops.

Eurogamer reported on November 21 that the user score stood at 5.6 out of 10 across more than 54,000 ratings, with 44 percent negative, and noted entries accusing the game of a "DEI" agenda. None of those outlets published a breakdown showing what percentage of negative entries came from two-game accounts or cultural objections, and SteamGame.ai has no basis to estimate that share. Even inside those same reports, however, non-game votes sat right beside product complaints, with Eurogamer citing the console frame-rate cap, bugs, and the story centered on Jason and Lucia's relationship, and GGRecon noting repeated zero-score mentions of the frame-rate cap and dislike of the story.

Three repeated complaints trace back to checkable product facts

Look past the two-game accounts, and three complaints repeating across Metacritic low scores and X posts turn out to be verified product decisions. Current consoles have no 60fps mode, including the PS5 Pro, with the Dexerto-affiliated account @GTAlphaintel reporting on November 21 that Rockstar said no current console is powerful enough to run Grand Theft Auto VI above 30fps. Retail physical editions ship with a download code and no disc inside the box, a packaging decision reported by both The Verge and BBC News on June 24.

CBS News on November 19 and The Verge on June 24 listed US retail pricing at $79.99 for the standard edition and $99.99 for the ultimate edition, while BBC News reported US prices as $79.99 and $100 on June 24. Those three points surfaced before a single Metacritic user score went live. Two days ahead of release, on November 17, X user @iamdpassword listed the console frame-rate lock, the absence of a launch PC version, and the disc-free physical box as complaints already dominating pre-launch replies.

Separately from those three product decisions, hardware crashes entered the launch conversation on PS5. On November 21, The Verge journalist Tom Warren posted that PS5 error code CE-108255-1 was stopping some people from playing Grand Theft Auto VI, calling the problem a poor fit with Sony's paid "plays best on PS5" marketing. Tom Warren pointed to reporting tied to a widely shared November 19 post by @ghost_motley, which showed photos of hardware errors and claimed the demanding game was exposing PS5 consoles that were not truly stable.

That crash claim sits outside the three confirmed product choices above, since @ghost_motley offered error photos without a formal benchmark. The channel also matters for the three confirmed complaints, because the frame-rate, disc, and pricing objections come from Metacritic explanations and X discussions, separate from the PlayStation Store's verified-buyer ratings.

Individual player accounts split sharply on the same launch build

Individual players describing their own launch-week sessions divide sharply over the game itself. On November 21, X user @SultanXEmir claimed 60 hours played from launch and a finished story before giving Grand Theft Auto VI a low score, praising the graphics and Vice City's detail while expressing dissatisfaction that the plot focused on the relationship between Lucia and Jason. On the same day, another player posting as @FrenchRapUS wrote after three days of play that the open world, NPC interactions, and random events felt unusually alive, calling Lucia a much stronger character than Jason so far and praising the PS5 Pro on an OLED screen.

CBS News on November 19 also quoted early players from New Zealand and a UK account spoofed to New Zealand praising immersion, visuals, and story. On the critical side of live broadcasts, a November 18 clip shared by @bloomjpg showed streamer Knut reacting on stream by advising viewers to wait for the PC version and saying the release fell short for 2026. Each of those accounts speaks for one player or one streamer, so none of them establishes a majority verdict on either side.

Where this judgment could be wrong

Four limits could weaken SteamGame.ai's reading of this split. Buyer ratings on the PlayStation Store come exclusively from people who already chose to pay for the game, creating self-selection bias that tends to pull verified-buyer averages upward. The three Metacritic user-score snapshots were taken at different times on November 21 and may not cover identical platform pages, because GGRecon specifically checked the PS5 page that morning while Eurogamer and jeuxvideo.com published separate readings.

SteamGame.ai has no review-level Metacritic dataset and cannot measure how much of the drop came from two-game accounts versus buyers frustrated by frame rates, packaging, or pricing. Grand Theft Auto VI also launched only days before these reports, leaving both verified-buyer averages and open-board scores open to movement as more people finish the campaign or encounter crashes.

How developers can separate noise from product signals

Studios tracking launch reception can avoid treating any single aggregate score as a final verdict on product quality. Teams can start by splitting purchase-gated storefronts from open-entry scoreboards, reading verified-buyer averages apart from platforms that let anyone post a rating without owning the game.

When an open scoreboard sinks, developers can audit the recurring text inside negative entries and pull out items tied directly to verifiable product decisions, such as frame-rate targets, physical box contents, and edition pricing. Reviewing those product-level grievances alongside individual long-session accounts from both satisfied and disappointed players gives teams concrete trade-offs to weigh before shipping updates or setting launch terms for a future release.

· · ·

Sources (date published):