Best new Mystery games

Subscribe via RSS

16 new Mystery games we reviewed, ranked by potential score.

1
Adventure · Detective

Funeral for the Sun Review

Sharp deduction, gorgeous hand-drawn mood, and a family tree worth untangling — Three things carry Funeral for the Sun at once: a connection map that keeps p…

Potential 9799% positive511 reviews2026-11-13
2
Adventure · Co-op

CRACK Review

Co-op chaos inside a giant egg, gone a little too soon — CRACK is a short, silly, polished piece of co-op labor, and the crew you bring matters more than any…

Potential 9491% positive2,846 reviews2026-11-15
3
Anime · Visual Novel

Psycho-Sleuth Review

Shaky first cases, then a killing game worth crying over — Psycho-Sleuth is a rough-cut mystery that earns its 91% on the strength of its people.

Potential 9491% positive1,860 reviews2026-11-15
4
Mystery · Puzzle

The Death Game Report Review

Two hours of clean document sleuthing, solved a little too fast — The Death Game Report is a two-hour deduction box that fits neatly into an evening and rare…

Potential 9096% positive2,562 reviews2026-11-15
5
Story Rich · Choices Matter

The Wolf Among Us Remastered Review

A gripping noir fable, minus the chapter select fans wanted — Anyone meeting Bigby for the first time gets a strong deal here: the writing, the performances…

Potential 8991% positive1,010 reviews2026-11-16
6
Psychological Horror · Investigation

lily's world XD Review

Meta horror that reaches your phone, wrapped around a sincere story — lily's world XD earns its standing on the parts a screenshot cannot show.

Potential 8796% positive1,851 reviews2026-11-15
7
Adventure · Mystery

Tales of Fear - Episode Zero Review

Three short horror tales, one true-or-fake guess, and no price of entry — Tales of Fear - Episode Zero makes a small idea work through execution.

Potential 8695% positive699 reviews2026-11-16
8
Mystery · Detective

Death at Fleming Manor Review

Clever forensic cases meet fussy menus and heavy paperwork. — Death at Fleming Manor brings a welcome medical angle to fill-in-the-blank deduction, trading p…

Potential 8282% positive619 reviews2026-11-17
9
Visual Novel · Anime

HoloTrials: Case Covered Review

Expressive animations, sharp courtroom comedy, and shockingly slick free-to-play presentation. — HoloTrials: Case Covered delivers the kind of visual flair,…

Potential 8198% positive448 reviews2026-11-17
10
Investigation · Dark Humor

Legion Was Here Review

Clever face-sculpting deduction meets randomized undercover exams and offbeat comedy. — Legion Was Here turns detective work into a high-pressure undercover…

Potential 7595% positive277 reviews2026-11-19
11
Lovecraftian · Third-Person Shooter

The Sinking City 2 Review

Arkham drowns beautifully, and veteran fans may not forgive what replaced it — The Sinking City 2 works better the less you expect a sequel.

Potential 7283% positive1,805 reviews2026-11-15
12
Co-op · Puzzle

We Were Here Tomorrow Review

Better-looking sci-fi sets, a long campaign, and co-op that thins out — The good will in We Were Here Tomorrow comes from its facility, its length and a smal…

Potential 6438% positive2,346 reviews2026-11-15
13
FMV · Choices Matter

AKIBA LOST Review

Polished Akihabara mystery visual novel slowed by filler and melodrama — AKIBA LOST pairs television-grade live-action photography and a charismatic ensemble…

Potential 6384% positive322 reviews2026-11-18
14
Horror · Visual Novel

Red Chat Ritual – TSUMIMI TIME Review

Gorgeous pixel art and lively voice acting outshine shallow trial-and-error deductions. — Red Chat Ritual – TSUMIMI TIME succeeds as an audiovisual mood pie…

Potential 6265% positive490 reviews2026-11-17
15
Early Access · Detective

Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker Review

A living Holmes cast, buried under bugs and rough edges — Detective Sherlock: Shadow Stalker is a working prototype of an idea worth chasing: type your quest…

Potential 5688% positive476 reviews2026-11-17
16
Horror · Psychological Horror

Rehaunted Review

Tense crime-scene sleuthing and sharp scares, dragged down by bugs and chases. — Rehaunted starts with a compelling hook, pairing crime-scene forensics with…

Potential 5170% positive451 reviews2026-11-17